Parents Should Tell Children What To Do, Not Ask.

Today's parents frequently complain that their children don't do as they are told.

That simply isn't true. Almost every child will do what he or she is told, most of the time. (I estimate the figure at more than 90 percent on both counts.) That's a fact, not a theory. The discrepancy between what is absolutely true about children (i.e., they will do what they are told) and what parents report (i.e., many of today's children do not generally do what they are told) is easily explained: Most of today's parents do not tell their children what to do. They ask. They even ask their children permission to ask. In addition to asking, they plead, bargain, cajole, and try to persuade, but they rarely, if ever, simply tell. Examples:

"Billy, don't you think it would be better if we did that some other day?"

"Roberta, Mommy would really rather you sat here, okay?"

"I think it's time you were in bed, Suzette, don't you?"

"Let's pick up these toys now, Rodney, OK?"

Do you recognize yourself in these examples, dear reader? If so, then I regret to tell you that you do not deserve obedient children. It is said that one gets what one asks for, and since you are asking, not telling, you deserve disobedience.

You also deserve insolence, petulance, disrespect and ungratefulness. If you are not getting all of the above, count yourself lucky, or blessed, or both. A parenting angel is probably standing behind you, saving you from the normal consequences of your wimpishness.

There is nothing, absolutely nothing, wrong with today's children that they cannot be expected to obey as well as did children 45 years ago, when I was 8. My peers and I were mischievous, for sure, but when given direct instruction by an adult, we obeyed. Immediately. Most of the time, that is, and given that all children descend from Adam and Eve, most of the time is as good as it gets. Not so with today's children. They do not obey most of the time, much less immediately, and they are often openly defiant, as in "I'm not going to" and "I don't want to." As I said above, this does not reflect a defect or defects in today's kids. We who are now becoming grandparents obeyed when we were children because our parents told us what to do. Examples:

"Billy, we're not going to do that today. Some other time perhaps."

"Roberta, Mommy wants you to sit right here. No, right here."

"Suzette, it's time for bed. Not tired, eh? Well then, my darling, you can stare at the ceiling until you are tired."

"I need you to pick up these toys right now, Rodney, and the television is going off until they are picked up and put away."

Today's parents suffer from DLS, or defective leadership syndrome. They apparently do not understand that parenting requires servant-ship during infancy and early toddlerhood and leadership from that point on. Above all else, good leaders act as if they know what they are doing, even when they are unsure. Good leaders never have to yell or demand attention in other, equally dramatic ways because they speak authoritatively, and authoritative speech commands attention.

If today's parents would simply serve when their children require service and lead when their children require leadership, their children would be grateful and obedient. Of that there is no doubt.

Copyright 2000, John Rosemond

Access hundreds of John's archived articles on his parenting membership website, For a limited time, save 20% off a one-year subscription. Use code FBSAVE20 at checkout.

Become A Member To Get More From ParentGuru®

Members enjoy access to all articles.


View All Articles